Is Judge Judy a Real Judge and Are The Courtroom Decisions Real? Here’s The Truth You Need To Know

Is Judge Judy a real judge? You better believe it!

On March 2, 2019, Judy Sheindlin — better known as “Judge Judy” — announced that the upcoming season of her namesake courtroom show would be it’s last. “I’ve had a 25-year-long marriage with CBS, and it’s been successful,” she shared on The Ellen DeGeneres Show, adding that a slate of new episodes will air throughout most of 2021. 

Thankfully, the 80-year-old isn’t ready to hand in her gavel just yet. She’s already working on another series. “I’m not tired, so Judy Justice will be coming out a year [after Judge Judy wraps],” the New York native said of her next project.

Her new show, Judy Justice is a spin-off of the courtroom series Judge Judy (1996–2021). The show features Sheindlin adjudicating real-life small-claims disputes within a simulated courtroom set. Prior to the proceedings, all involved parties sign arbitration contracts agreeing to Sheindlin’s ruling.

Judge Judy first appeared on camera at age 53. Sheindlin spent 25 years in New York’s Family Court, during which she heard more than 20,000 cases.

Though she’s arguably the most famous magistrate in the country, Judy’s qualifications are constantly being called into question. So, is she the real deal or is she faking it for the cameras?

Is Judge Judy a real judge?

The mother of five is a full-fledged prosecution lawyer and judge, having passed the state bar exam and gotten her degree from New York Law School in 1965.

is judge judy a real judge

After nearly 20 years as an attorney, former New York Mayor Ed Koch appointed her to a criminal court judgeship in 1982. Four years later, she became the supervising judge of the Manhattan Family Court.

If anyone was meant for reality TV it’s Judy. The best-selling author developed a reputation for being relentless and sarcastic on the bench, characteristics she claimed were necessary for survival in her line of work. 

“There’s a sense of utter hopelessness here, and you can’t let it get to you,” Judy told the Los Angeles Times in 1993, three years before landing her syndicated series. “You get the distinct feeling of people disintegrating, or on the verge of it. And there’s only so much you can do to help.”

are judge judy courtroom decisions real

Are the ‘Judge Judy’ courtroom decisions real?

The show’s cases are relatively tame compared to what Judy witnessed during her years in family court, but the small claim disputes she deals with now are still 100 percent authentic. All parties involved signing an arbitration contract before appearing in the courtroom, agreeing that Judy’s judgment is final and cannot be pursued elsewhere. 

In 2015, a potential defendant shared a letter he/she received from one of the series’ producers which outlined the process further. Yes, the decisions rendered are “legally binding,” but participants on both sides are guaranteed to make money from the on-camera stint.

Not only does Judge Judy provide an appearance fee for both plaintiffs and defendants, but CBS also pays for travel expenses. Furthermore, if the plaintiff wins a monetary award from the defendant, the show covers the cost, meaning the person getting sued doesn’t have to pay a dime. 

No wonder so many people have agreed to televise their legal troubles.

chrissys court

Not every arbitration-based court show is legit.

Fans were both confused and delighted when model/reigning queen of Twitter Chrissy Teigen announced that she would be hosting her own Judge Judy-esque program called Chrissy’s Court. The brunette beauty serves as the decision maker while her mother, Vilailuck “Pepper Thai” Teigen, takes on the role of bailiff. 

The 10-minute episodes (which will air on the mobile-video subscription service Quibi) aren’t meant to be taken seriously and any “judgments” made by Chrissy have no legal merit. “I have seen every episode and I just cannot believe something can be so silly, so petty, and so funny,” the TV personality tweeted in January. “I am so proud of it and can’t wait for you guys to see it!!”

Maybe Chrissy’s Court and Judy Justice can do a crossover!